Home Warranty Now vs American Home Shield: Quick Facts
| Feature | Home Warranty Now | American Home Shield |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2018 | 1971 |
| Starting monthly price | Varies by plan and region | Varies by plan and region |
| Service fee (typical) | $75 -- $125 per claim | $75 -- $125 per claim |
| HVAC coverage | Available | Available |
| Appliance coverage | Varies by plan | Varies by plan |
| Waiting period | 30 days (standard) | 30 days (standard) |
Pricing and coverage details change frequently. Always confirm current pricing directly with each company before purchasing.
Coverage: What Each Company Protects
Both Home Warranty Now and American Home Shield offer tiered plans that cover major home systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical) and appliances at different price points. The key differences typically involve:
- Whether the base plan includes both heating and cooling or requires a higher tier
- Appliance coverage -- some companies include appliances in the base plan; others require an add-on
- Coverage caps per system per contract period
- Optional add-ons (pool equipment, additional refrigerators, well pumps)
Before choosing either company, request a sample contract and compare the coverage caps for HVAC, the most common and most expensive claim category.
Pricing and Service Fees
Home warranty pricing varies by state, plan level, and the size of the home. Both Home Warranty Now and American Home Shield publish pricing online, but the rates shown at the start of a quote may not reflect the final annual price after all fees. The service fee -- the amount paid to the technician per visit -- adds to the total cost of ownership over a year.
When comparing total annual cost: multiply the monthly premium by 12, then add the expected number of service calls multiplied by the service fee. A plan with a lower monthly premium but a higher service fee can cost more overall if you file multiple claims in a year.
Customer Reviews: Home Warranty Now vs American Home Shield
Customer reviews for both companies are publicly available on the Better Business Bureau (bbb.org), Trustpilot, and Consumer Affairs. When reading reviews for any home warranty company, focus on:
- Claim approval and denial rates mentioned in reviews
- Technician response time and scheduling experience
- Payout for covered repairs versus actual replacement cost
- Customer service experience during disputes
Both Home Warranty Now and American Home Shield have a mix of positive and negative reviews. No home warranty company has a perfect record across all reviewers.
How to Decide Between Home Warranty Now and American Home Shield
The right company depends on your specific situation:
- Age of systems: If your HVAC or water heater is more than 10 years old, check each company's policy on pre-existing conditions and coverage limits for older equipment.
- Budget: Calculate total annual cost (12 x monthly premium + expected service fees) rather than just the monthly sticker price.
- Contract flexibility: Check the cancellation policy before you commit. Some companies charge a fee for early cancellation.
- Read the sample contract: Both companies are required to provide a sample contract on request. Read it before you purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Neither company is universally better. The right choice depends on your state, your home's systems, the age of your appliances, and your budget. Compare sample contracts from both before deciding.
Yes, but most contracts require a cancellation notice period (30 days is common) and may charge a cancellation fee for early termination. Check the cancellation terms before switching.
Standard exclusions include pre-existing conditions, cosmetic damage, secondary damage caused by a covered failure, and items outside the coverage caps. Read the exclusions section of any contract carefully.