Top Home Warranty Companies
Choosing the right home warranty means comparing coverage, contractor networks, service call fees, and customer satisfaction across providers. Below you will find detailed reviews and comparisons for the leading home warranty companies serving homeowners nationwide.
American Home Shield
American Home Shield is the country's largest home warranty provider, covering millions of homes across all 50 states since 1971.
Founded 1971 • BBB: B • 14,000+ reviews
Read Reviews →Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty offers affordable, comprehensive plans with no home inspection requirement and 24/7 claims support.
Founded 2008 • BBB: B • 7,500+ reviews
Read Reviews →First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty, backed by Fortune 500 financial giant First American Financial Corporation, brings institutional stability and an A+ BBB rating to home protection.
Founded 1984 • BBB: A+ • 5,200+ reviews
Read Reviews →2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty pioneered the structural home warranty in 1980 and now offers comprehensive coverage for both new construction and resale homes.
Founded 1980 • BBB: A+ • 3,800+ reviews
Read Reviews →Cinch Home Services
Cinch Home Services (formerly Cross Country Home Services) brings over 45 years of home warranty experience, covering both home systems and appliances.
Founded 1978 • BBB: B • 4,100+ reviews
Read Reviews →Liberty Home Guard
Liberty Home Guard has quickly become one of the highest-rated home warranty companies in the country, earning top marks from homeowners for responsive customer service.
Founded 2017 • BBB: A+ • 5,800+ reviews
Read Reviews →AFC Home Club
AFC Home Club offers flexible home warranty plans with the unique option to use your own licensed contractor, giving homeowners more control over their repair experience.
Founded 2008 • BBB: B+ • 3,200+ reviews
Read Reviews →Select Home Warranty
Select Home Warranty provides budget-friendly home protection with 24/7 claims service and coverage for homes regardless of system age.
Founded 2012 • BBB: B • 4,600+ reviews
Read Reviews →What to Compare When Choosing a Home Warranty
- Coverage scope: Does the plan cover both home systems and appliances, or only one?
- HVAC coverage caps: HVAC is the most expensive covered system - look for the highest cap you can find in your budget.
- Service call fee: This is what you pay per visit. Lower fees mean higher premiums; higher fees mean lower premiums.
- Contractor network: Does the provider have vetted contractors in your area with strong response times?
- BBB rating and customer reviews: Look at both the BBB rating and third-party review platforms for a complete picture.
- Claim process: Is claims filing available 24/7? How long does it typically take to get a technician dispatched?
Direct Comparisons
For a detailed side-by-side comparison of two specific companies, visit one of our comparison pages: